Coluna / Columna v.15, n.4 /2016

ARTIGO ORIGINAL

ANÁLISE RETROSPECTIVA COMPARATIVA DO TRATAMENTO CIRÚRGICO DA FRATURA TORACOLOMBAR DO TIPO EXPLOSÃO: FIXAÇÃO CURTA VERSUS LONGA


RETROSPECTIVE COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SURGICAL TREATMENT OF THORACOLUMBAR BURST FRACTURE: SHORT LONG FIXATION


ANÁLISIS RETROSPECTIVO COMPARATIVO DEL TRATAMIENTO QUIRÚRGICO DE FRACTURA TORACOLUMBAR POR EXPLOSIÓN: FIJACIÓN CORTA VERSUS LARGA


Carlos Alberto de Almeida de Assunção Filho1 , Nelson Astur1 , João Paulo Bergamaschi1 , Luciano Antonio Nassar Pellegrino1 , Ricardo Shigueaki1 , Galhego Umeta1 , Maria Fernanda Silber Caffaro1 , Osmar Avanzi1 , Robert Meves1

1 . Faculdade de Ciências Médicas da Santa Casa de São Paulo (FCMSCSP), São Paulo, SP, Brazil.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/



RESUMO

Objetivo:

Métodos:

Resultados:

Conclusão:


Palavras-chave: Fraturas da coluna vertebral/terapia,Vértebras lombares,Vértebras torácicas.

ABSTRACT

Objective:
The objective of this study is to compare short posterior fixation to long posterior fixation in thoracolumbar burst fractures.

Methods:
Fifty-three patients were divided into Group I (n=24) treated with short instrumentation (one level above and one below the fracture) and into Group II (n=29) treated with long instrumentation (two or more levels above and below the fracture). The load sharing classification was used to stratify cases. The evaluation of the sagittal index was performed using the Cobb method.

Results:
In subgroups with load sharing classification ≤ 6, Group I had loss of correction of 4.2 degrees and a procedure failure in 14.3% of cases, Group II showed loss of correction of 5.4 degrees and failure in 21.7% of cases. In subgroups with load sharing classification ≥7, Group I had a loss of correction of 11.2 degrees and procedure failure in 70% of cases, and Group II showed a loss of correction of 9 degrees and failure of 46.7%. Group I had a tendency to worse outcomes, especially in the subgroup of patients with load sharing classification ≥7.

Conclusion:
Despite the tendency for poorer results in the short fixation group in the cases with load sharing ≥7, in no sample was there statistically significant difference between the groups studied.


Keywords: Spinal fractures/therapy,Lumbar vertebrae,Thoracic vertebrae.

Resumen

Objetivo:

Métodos:

Resultados:
Load Sharing

Conclusiones:


Palavras-chave: Fracturas de la columna vertebral/terapia,Vértebras lumbares,Vértebras torácicas.






Indexadores